Jeff Wyler Automotive Group
Sell Your Car in Ohio, Indiana or Kentucky
Whether you're upgrading to a new vehicle or simply ready to part with your current ride, our dealership is here to offer a hassle-free selling experience backed by trusted tools like the Kelley Blue Book Instant Cash Offer.
1
Simple
Get your free online valuation in seconds with the Kelly Blue Book Instant Cash Offer tool directly on our website.
2
Safe
Visit our closest dealership location for vehicle inspection and final offer. Professional, secure environment with experienced staff.
3
Secure
Get your check on the spot or within 3 business days. We handle all paperwork, DMV transfers, and loan payoffs.
Sell Your Car Stress-Free
Get an Instant Offer Backed by Kelley Blue Book
We understand that knowing the true value of your car is the first step in selling it confidently. That's why we provide access to the Kelley Blue Book Instant Cash Offer tool right on our website. Use this tool to enter your vehicle details and receive a personalized offer in minutes. This cash offer is based on real-time market data and backed by one of the most trusted names in the automotive industry. You can redeem it at our dealership with zero pressure to buy.
Why Sell to Jeff Wyler?
Selling your car privately can take time and involve unnecessary stress. From scheduling test drives with strangers to negotiating prices and handling paperwork, it's a lot to manage on your own. At Jeff Wyler, we streamline the process and offer you peace of mind with a fair, market-based offer. Our team handles all the documentation, and you'll receive payment quickly. No guesswork, no hidden fees, and no runaround.
We Give You Options
Trade-In or Sell Your Vehicle Outright
We give you options. If you're looking to upgrade to a new Vehicle, your trade-in value can be applied directly to your purchase, helping lower your down payment or monthly financing costs. Not ready to buy? No problem. We'll still buy your car, even if you don't purchase anything from us. No matter where you are, you can sell your car to us with no obligation to buy.
What to Expect When Selling Your Car
The process is simple and straightforward. Start by using the Kelley Blue Book Instant Cash Offer tool from our website. Then, bring your vehicle to one of our dealerships for a quick in-person inspection. Be sure to bring your vehicle title, registration, photo ID, and any loan payoff information if applicable. Our team will verify your offer, walk you through the process, and answer any questions you may have. Most offers are honored the same day, so you can leave with a check in hand, quickly and confidently.
Ready to Sell Your Car?
Get your free, no-obligation quote today and see why thousands of drivers choose Jeff Wyler.
Start Your Free Valuation
FAQ
 Trading in your car at Jeff Wyler is designed to be fast and stress-free. We’ll appraise your vehicle on the spot to determine its fair market value based on make, model, year, mileage, and condition. Once we agree on a value, that amount becomes an instant credit toward your next purchase, lowering your out-of-pocket cost or monthly payment. We even handle all the paperwork, including paying off any remaining loan balance if you still owe on your vehicle. Most customers complete the entire trade-in and purchase process the same day — no waiting, no hassle, just a smooth transition to your next ride.
 While sites like Kelley Blue Book (KBB) are helpful for ballpark estimates, the most accurate way to find your car’s true market value is with an in-person appraisal at Jeff Wyler. Our experts inspect your specific vehicle — not just its model — factoring in real-world condition, service history, optional features, and current local market trends. You can visit any Jeff Wyler dealership for a free, no-obligation appraisal and receive a firm offer you can use whether you decide to trade in or sell outright.
 Several key elements determine your trade-in value, including your car’s make, model, year, mileage, and condition. Our appraisers also review your service records, any past accidents (including diminished value), tire and brake condition, and interior wear. Popular, well-maintained models in high demand often command higher offers. Even small details — like having both key fobs or clean maintenance documentation — can make a difference. We evaluate every vehicle fairly using real market data to ensure you get a transparent, accurate value.
 Yes, you can trade in your leased vehicle early at Jeff Wyler. We’ll contact your leasing company to verify the payoff amount, appraise your vehicle’s value, and review whether you have equity (worth more than the payoff) or negative equity (worth less). If you have equity, you can apply it toward your next vehicle. If not, we’ll discuss rolling the difference into a new finance plan. This is a popular option for Toyota and Honda lease returns, which often retain strong resale value.
 At lease-end, you have several choices. You can return your vehicle, buy it through an end-of-lease buyout, trade it toward another vehicle, or simply turn it in and walk away (subject to any mileage or wear fees). Buying your lease lets you keep a car you already know and trust, while trading it can capture any equity and make upgrading simple. Many Toyota and other brand lease returns that come through our stores are reconditioned and offered for sale in our pre-owned inventory — great for the next driver, and great for you if you’re moving into something new.
 Our appraisals are quick — typically 20 to 30 minutes from start to finish. During that time, we’ll inspect the vehicle’s interior, exterior, and mechanical systems, review a vehicle history report, and check for any damage or wear. Once complete, we’ll present a written offer on the spot. If you decide to move forward, we can start the trade-in or purchase paperwork immediately. The entire process is designed for convenience and transparency — no long waits, just fair numbers you can trust.
 No appointment is necessary — you can stop by any Jeff Wyler location for a free appraisal anytime during business hours. However, scheduling ahead online or by phone helps minimize wait time and ensures a dedicated appraiser is ready when you arrive. We have locations across Ohio, Kentucky, and Indiana, all offering professional evaluations with no obligation to sell. Whether you’re trading in or just curious about your car’s value, we’re happy to provide an expert assessment.
 Absolutely. Jeff Wyler buys vehicles outright — no purchase required. Bring your car, truck, or SUV to any of our locations for a fast, free appraisal and a same-day cash offer. If you accept, we handle all the paperwork and payment on the spot. We buy everything from nearly new vehicles to older models, making it the simplest and fastest way to sell your car without dealing with private listings, strangers, or online scams.
 Yes, we will. If you still have an active loan, we’ll contact your lender to confirm the payoff amount and handle the balance directly. If your car’s value exceeds what you owe, you’ll receive the difference as cash or as credit toward another vehicle. If you owe slightly more, we can help structure a new deal that rolls the balance into your next purchase. Either way, we take care of the details with your lender so you don’t have to.
 To make your appraisal as smooth as possible, bring your vehicle’s title or lease agreement, current registration, all keys and remotes, and maintenance records if available. You’ll also need your driver’s license and, if applicable, details about your existing loan or lease (lender name and account number). Service history and receipts for recent repairs or upgrades can sometimes improve your offer. If you’re missing any documents, don’t worry — our team can help you locate what’s needed to complete the process.
Not all vehicles will qualify. The Jeff Wyler Automotive Family, Inc. reserves the right to decline any purchase at the discretion of management. Purchase value is subject to adjustment for mileage, condition and current market conditions. The seller must be the registered owner of the vehicle and have a valid driver's license or other form of valid government issued photo identification, as shown on the title and/or registration. The seller must provide a valid registration and either clear and unencumbered title in the seller's name, or complete documentation regarding any lease or lien obligations or liens on the vehicle (including, for example, contact information for the lender or leasing company, relevant account information, and the current loan payoff amount or lease buyout amount including any fees for the vehicle). Any liens or fees will be deducted from the amount paid to the seller. In the event that the seller's loan balance exceeds the amount of the company's offer, it will be the seller's responsibility for paying the difference with certified funds to complete the transaction. If same day payment is not available, payment will typically be issued within three (3) business days of all requested documentation being completed and, the vehicle being delivered to the company, as well as the company receiving the physical title (with lien release, if applicable). Some circumstances may lengthen this time frame. See company for additional details.